Finns follow the pulp project conflict
in Southern America with calm concern
Helsinki (24.03.2006 - Juhani Artto) The huge pulp project in Fray Bentos in
Uruguay has aroused local people, and even governments, to come out strongly for it or
actively fight against it. In Finland too, thousands of miles away from the scene of the
controversy, many people, thanks to coverage by the major news fora, have been following
events with interest.
The reason is obvious. This project is, outside Finland, the largest single
investment by Finnish industry. Two Finnish forest industry giants, UPM-Kymmene and the Metsäliitto Group, are behind the project, which will cost about
EUR800 million and create a mill with a capacity to produce a million tons of pulp
annually.
Except for experts working for the major environmental organisations, such as Greenpeace
and Friends of Earth, the project has not, so far, become a divisive issue for Finns.
There has been no real movement demanding changes to the project, let alone giving it up.
Criticism by the environmentalists has mainly focused on the planned bleaching and waste
water treatment technologies.
As these do not, in any significant manner, differ from the technological solutions widely in use in Finland, ordinary Finns are not unduly worried
about the Fray Bentos mill's environmental impact on its surroundings.
Finnish pulp industry used to be a bad polluter
Up until the 1960s the Finnish pulp and paper industry did not pay much attention to the
negative environmental impact. But, as mill surrounding areas, especially down-stream
lakes and rivers, became more and more polluted, people gradually began to take a strong
stand against industry practices.
With some delay, investments to reduce discharges followed. However, in the late 1960s
people's concern about the pollution problem somehow ran ahead of environmental investments. Limits to the protest
movements were set by the fact that a large proportion of the people, living near to the
pulp and paper mills, directly or indirectly, earned their living from the industry.
Anyway, people's anger in many parts of Finland and visible protests
continued in the early 1970s.
Fortunately, the industry gradually also recognised another reason to invest in its
processes in order to reduce discharges. That was the cost factor. In many cases, it was
found that raising the utilisation rate of raw-materials and chemicals was financially
beneficial.
Lately major struggles have focused on forests
Since the late 1970s Finnish worries about the environmental impact of pulp and paper
production have mainly focused on forests. The major struggles concern the protection of
species and biodiversity. Even in the last few years, several local disputes, which have
received national attention, have surfaced in different parts of the country.
Forest and land use have been among the most critical issues in a few
struggles in the third world where the largest Finnish pulp and paper
multinationals have, in the last few years, been involved. The countries
concerned have been Indonesia, Thailand and Brazil.
Uruguay project also creates employment
in Finland
Finland's machine building industry plays a leading global role as the
provider of pulp and paper production machinery. In respect of the Fray Bentos project in Uruguay, Finnish providers are
responsible for a significant part of the process machinery. Partly, at least, this machinery is even assembled
in Finland, according to project sources.
So, in the meantime, the project will keep busy a good number of
experts and skilled workers in the Finnish engineering industry.
Read more:
|